Skip to main content

From draft to delivery: practical lessons from 15 National Building Renovation Plans

Scaffolding and insulation works on a residential building under renovation.
Technical Article
European Countries

From draft to delivery: practical lessons from 15 National Building Renovation Plans

Drawing on CLIMACT’s assessment of 15 draft National Building Renovation Plans for Renovate Europe, the European Environmental Bureau and nine other organisations, this article highlights promising measures and how stakeholders can help strengthen final plans before the December 2026 deadline.

Editorial Team

Authors

Afroditi Psatha, Renovate Europe Campaign | LinkedIn profile

Quentin Jossen, CLIMACT | LinkedIn profile

Laetitia Aumont, European Environmental Bureau (EEB) | LinkedIn profile

(Note: Opinions in the articles are of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the European Union)


Introduction

Buildings account for around 40% of the EU's final energy consumption and remain heavily reliant on fossil fuels. In 2024, natural gas, oil and coal still supplied 41.7% of residential final energy consumption through direct use (Eurostat, 2024 data). Under the recast Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (EPBD), National Building Renovation Plans (NBRPs) are where each Member State sets out how its building stock will reach zero emissions by 2050. Final plans are due by 31 December 2026, shifting the focus from their objectives to the measures, budgets, and delivery structures needed to reach those aims. 

An assessment carried out by CLIMACT for Renovate Europe, the European Environmental Bureau (EEB) and nine other industry and civil society organisations reviewed 15 draft plans from Austria, Belgium-Wallonia, Bulgaria, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain and Sweden. A first round covering six of them was published on BUILD UP in June. This article goes further and covers the Commission's feedback on the drafts, published on 14 July 2026, and the Renovate Europe EPBD Tracker, which follows EPBD implementation in all 27 Member States. The results are largely positive. All 15 drafts commit to long-term decarbonisation, and each contains at least one instrument that others could adopt. The next step is to build on the measures already included in the plans and define a budget, legal basis and timeline. This is a good time for national stakeholders to help ministries make these improvements before the final plans are submitted.

 

Room for improvement: the Commission asked Member States to strengthen their final plans 

By mid-October 2026, 19 of the 27 Member States had submitted a draft plan to the Commission. On 14 July 2026, the Commission published its feedback on 16 drafts, with 145 requests for improvement in total. Together, these requests form a useful checklist for anyone commenting on a final plan. Every country was asked for clearer targets and trajectories and for more detail on financing, including how measures will be funded after 2030. Fifteen were asked to strengthen their approach to energy poverty, in several cases by setting reduction targets for 2040 and 2050 and explaining how the energy poverty rate is calculated. Fourteen were asked to strengthen their minimum energy performance standards (MEPS), and 10 to show how their measures lead to a full phase-out of fossil fuel boilers by 2040.

 

The drafts are clear on objectives and now need budgets, legal bases, timelines, and stronger social safeguards 

The CLIMACT assessment assesses each plan across 18 topics, from renovation trajectories and one-stop shops to the rental market and climate resilience. Each topic is scored across eight dimensions, using a scale from 0 (absent) to 3 (fully operational), with 2.0 taken as the level at which a measure is ready to be delivered. Scores are based only on the content of each NBRP. A national measure that is in force but not described in the plan does not count, which partly explains the lower scores of concise plans such as Denmark's. 

 

Bar chart comparing average assessment scores across eight dimensions in 15 draft NBRPs, with explicitness scoring highest at 2.04 and social robustness lowest at 1.10.

Figure 1. Average score by assessment dimension across the 15 draft NBRPs and 18 topics. Source: CLIMACT, ‘The delivery challenge of NBRPs: Executive narrative (Document 3)’, October 2026, Figure 3.

 

As Figure 1 shows, the plans are clear about what they intend to do: explicitness (2.04) is the only dimension above the 2.0 threshold, and maturity follows close behind. Delivery credibility (1.49), evaluability (1.24) and social robustness (1.10) are lower, which shows that the plans give less detail on who delivers, how progress is measured and who bears the cost. In practice, the drafts describe relevant measures but often leave out the budgets, legal bases, start dates, or monitoring arrangements that would let a household, a contractor or a bank plan an investment or a renovation project. 

Each plan has its own strengths. Spain stands out on finance and social measures, Romania and Belgium-Wallonia on delivery structures, Denmark on targets and standards, and Belgium-Wallonia on long-term quality. No single plan leads in more than two of the five topic clusters (targets, delivery, finance, social measures and long-term quality), so each administration can learn from the others.

 

Social robustness, the lowest-scoring dimension, varies widely by topic

When the plans deal with energy poverty, the rental market or social safeguards, their social robustness is close to the delivery-ready level. On technical topics such as zero-emission thresholds, public building obligations or non-residential minimum energy performance standards, the score drops by about half. These sections rarely assess which owners and tenants will have to pay for the works and whether they can afford them. Overall, only 5 of the 15 plans (Belgium-Wallonia, France, the Netherlands, Slovenia and Spain) score above the delivery-ready threshold in this dimension. In the final plans, social frameworks have to become more operational, and they must address the split incentive problem between landlords and tenants. Across the 15 plans, three main approaches can be identified: prohibitions (France), rent caps linked to energy performance (the Netherlands and Belgium-Wallonia), and the transfer of energy or carbon costs to landlords (Sweden and Germany). Each approach should be accompanied by financing instruments that are accessible to tenants and other non-owners. 

 

Heating and building data: two areas where final plans can go further 

The first is the move away from fossil heating. The plans that outline a transition away from fossil heating support their approach with figures on the heating stock or with binding rules. Denmark plans to cut the number of oil and gas boilers from about 330,000 in 2023 to 36,000 in 2040, with oil boilers phased out by 2035. Finland expects about 1.6 million heat pumps. All plans rely on heat pumps and heat networks, but the Netherlands is the only plan that treats electricity grid capacity as a condition for its renovation trajectory: since 1 January 2026, housing has been a priority category for grid connections in congested areas. Final plans should also consider heating and cooling systems alongside the building envelope, and link renovation priorities to local heating and cooling plans, electricity network planning and neighbourhood programmes. An improved building envelope lowers heat demand and the network capacity needed, while the availability of district heating or grid capacity shapes which solutions suit each area. 

The second is data. Romania built its plan on a one-off extraction of some 500,000 energy performance certificates (EPCs) because no operational register existed at the time (its national digital building register pilot went live in July 2026). Setting up such a register takes several years, so final plans should already state which data will be collected, who manages it, and how often it is updated. Without this, Member States will not be able to show whether renovation rates are rising. 

 

Four questions national stakeholders can raise with their ministry before 31 December 

Many ministries are still revising their drafts. Industry associations, local authorities, energy agencies, financial institutions and civil society organisations can make those discussions more concrete by asking four questions drawn from the assessment. Table 1 shows each question with an example from a draft plan. 

 

QuestionWhat to ask Example from the draft plans 
VolumeHow much renovation does the plan expect each year, at what depth and in which building segments? Portugal splits its trajectory into light, medium and deep renovation; Slovenia sets rates by building type. 
StatusDoes each measure have a budget, a legal basis and a start date? Romania publishes thresholds with their calculation method and the relevant legal act; France and Denmark have binding requirements already in force (rental bans and whole-life carbon limits). 
MeansWho delivers the plan, and are advice and administration funded separately from the works? Romania has a dedicated budget line for one-stop shops; the Netherlands funds municipal staff. 
MonitoringHow will progress be tracked across the building stock, individual measures and wider benefits? Spain quantifies health and social benefits; Romania gives a ratio of benefits per euro invested. 

Table 1. Four questions that decide whether a final NBRP can be delivered, with examples from the draft plans. Source: CLIMACT, ‘The delivery challenge of NBRPs: Executive narrative (Document 3)’, October 2026, pp. 1 and 34.

 

  • Volume: Companies, lenders and training providers need annual volumes by segment and depth to plan their own capacity. Portugal links each renovation depth to primary energy thresholds, Slovenia sets its rates by period as well as by building type, and Spain raises its renovation rate to 445,500 dwellings a year by 2030. 
  • Status: Romania's draft plan sets out proposed non-residential MEPS thresholds in kWh/m² per year, based on an analysis of existing EPC data, and identifies compliance milestones in 2030 and 2033. France has written a calendar of rental bans for the worst-performing dwellings into law. Denmark's whole-life carbon limits for new buildings have been binding since 2023 and were tightened from 12 to about 7.1 kg carbon dioxide equivalent/m² per year in 2025, with further 10% cuts agreed for 2027 and 2029. Where a measure is still at the design stage, as with Spain's newest financing products, stakeholders can ask when it will start and with what budget. 
  • Means: Romania sets aside €1.81 billion for 2026 to 2030 for one-stop shops, technical assistance, vulnerable households, administration and awareness, equivalent to about 6% of its planned investment in renovation works over the same period, with a stated cost of €250,000 to open an office and €250,000 a year to run it. The Netherlands funds the staff municipalities need for their new tasks, and when the national insulation tranche opened in 2024, 340 of the 342 municipalities applied. Continuity matters as much as the amount: support that stops and restarts makes households and companies postpone their decisions. 
  • Monitoring: Spain’s is the only plan to fill in the Annex II investment-needs table completely and to quantify energy poverty reduction, avoided deaths and gross domestic product effects. Romania expresses its wider benefits as a single ratio per euro invested, an indicator that finance ministries can compare with other public investments. 

Answering these questions means setting clear budgets, timelines and responsibilities for measures already included in the plans. Table 2 shows where to find a good practice for other recurring topics. 

 

To strengthen Where to look 
Turning targets into renovation activity Slovenia, for rates by building type and period; Romania and Spain, for modelled trajectories with intermediate milestones; Portugal, for a residential trajectory split by renovation depth. 
Regulatory thresholds and their route into law Romania, for numeric values by typology and climate zone with a stated adoption route; Denmark, for binding whole-life carbon values on a dated tightening path; France, for rental phase-out dates written into law. 
The heating transition Denmark and Finland, for the most explicit heat-source trajectories. 
Financing that reaches every profile Spain, for instrument diversity and for declaring which products are operational; Belgium-Wallonia, for tiering by household profile; Slovenia, for publishing the residual shortfall by sector and period. 
Converting eligibility into access Spain, for direct payment to the contractor; Romania, for turnkey delivery with protected timelines. 
Delivery capacity France, for an advisory network covering 92% of the territory; Romania, for published unit costs, a legal basis and a dedicated delivery budget line; the Netherlands, for funding the municipal organisation that exercises devolved powers. 
Workforce planning Poland, Romania and Bulgaria. 
Place-based sequencing Belgium-Wallonia, for proposed zoning combining heat planning, vulnerability and climate exposure; Romania, for district-level indicators; Croatia, for coupling seismic and energy renovation. 
Renovation and the electricity network the Netherlands, the only plan treating connection capacity as a constraint on the renovation trajectory. 
The rental market France, for progressive prohibition enforceable by the tenant; the Netherlands, for legal rent tied to the energy label; Belgium-Wallonia, for rent conditioned on performance, still in design. 
Climate resilience Belgium-Wallonia and Spain, the only two treating it as part of renovation. 

Table 2. Where a working example can be found among the 15 draft NBRPs. Source: CLIMACT, ‘The delivery challenge of NBRPs: Executive narrative (Document 3)’, October 2026, section 4.1, p. 33-34.

 

Only the plans from Belgium-Wallonia and Spain treat climate resilience as part of renovation. Buildings renovated today will face more frequent overheating and other climate risks over their lifetime. Belgium-Wallonia will require an adaptation component in every energy audit from 2030, which helps avoid works that cut energy use but leave these risks unaddressed.

 

A solution that works in one country is often still missing in another

Exchanges between ministries and agencies already operating an instrument and those preparing to introduce one, for example on funding one-stop shops or setting MEPS thresholds, would be a useful way to close these gaps. The Commission should support this by assessing delivery-readiness alongside compliance when it reviews the final plans and by setting up a common monitoring framework that helps Member States build national building databases.

 

Following each country's progress with the Renovate Europe EPBD Tracker

National policy keeps changing after a plan is submitted. Following implementation therefore means watching both the plan and the national legislation, calculation methods and funding schemes that apply in each country. 

That is what the Renovate Europe EPBD Tracker is designed to do. Launched on 5 November 2026, it follows all 27 Member States across six policy modules: map the stock, plan the route, set the standards, activate smart performance, cut the carbon and enable delivery. It shows, for example, which countries have adopted MEPS or a zero-emission building definition, where one-stop shops already cover the whole territory, and which countries have a pathway out of fossil heating. A comparison page shows how each country addresses the same topic.

 

Conclusions

The 15 drafts give Europe a solid base: shared long-term goals and a set of good practices replicable across Member States. The final plans can build on that base, with Member States learning from what already works elsewhere. Renovate Europe sees three priorities: (i) a stable and coherent framework in which targets, measures and funding go hand in hand, so that industry can plan its investments; (ii) continuity in national financing schemes and requirements, so that households and companies are not held back by a stop-and-go approach to building policy; and (iii) financing that mobilises private capital, using public money to de-risk projects and attract private investment through renovation loans, green mortgages, public guarantees and energy performance contracting, while keeping full grants for vulnerable households and the worst-performing buildings. In the coming weeks, we encourage national stakeholders to engage on these topics directly with their ministries.